12 Days of Turkey, Bargain Meal of the Week, Cheesy Chicken and Pasta Casserole, Chicken, Freezer, Frugal Hausfrau, Leftover Chicken, Leftover Chicken Casserole, Leftover Turkey, Leftovers, Pasta, Super Easy Meal, Thanksgiving Leftovers, Turkey, Turkey leftovers, Velveeta
I know you’ll think I’m nuts when you see the Velveeta in the recipe – I rarely use Velveeta except for Grilled Cheese, but here it is…in this Cheesy Chicken (or Turkey) Casserole. *L* I feel like I should apologize - except this is a dynamite casserole! If you’re offended by the velveeta and canned soup, by all means make a roux using chicken broth and add cheese: ”Put Your Own Spin on It,” below.
Cheesy Chicken (or Turkey) Noodle Casserole, serves 12, and costs around $4.60 to make. I often divide it into two: I make one and freeze one (it freezes extremely well) or I’ll make one and give one when I know someone who’s been ill, moved, had a baby, etc. It screams comfort, it’s easy, and it consistently surprises me how people just seem to love it – and I’ve served it to neighbors, friends, church funerals and to the occasional “Gourmand.”
I never tell anyone how its made! Let that be our little secret! – I’ve been making this for 20 years or so, ever since a friend of my Mom’s, and a caterer, Kay Waugh, served it at my Sister’s wedding way back in the 80′s. This recipe was in her cookbook, “If It’s Good, It’s Gourmet.” I did cut back on the butter in the recipe, and usually make it with leftovers. Kay poached her chicken, then cooked the noodles in the broth. She also had sliced green olives in it, which my kids hated with a passion, so I omitted them – if you love them add them back in.
Recipe: Cheesy Chicken (or Turkey) Noodle Casserole, serves 12, cost $4.62
- 2 cups white meat chicken, or turkey
1 cup chopped green bell pepper
1 cup chopped onion
1 cup chopped celery
3 tablespoons butter
1 1/2 cups Velveeta, cubed, about 8 ounces
1 can sliced mushroom, or freshly sliced, sautéed in butter
2 cans cream of chicken soup, or celery or mushroom or substitute “cream of anything soup.”
1 cup chicken broth, may be reserved from cooking chicken or turkey
14 ounces spinach egg noodles, whole wheat or high protein pasta (you can use a pound)
4 ounces slivered almonds or bread crumbs
If not using leftovers, cook poultry in broth. (Reserve about a cup of the broth in case sauce needs to be thinned.)
Cook noodles till al dente.
Saute vegetables in the butter until tender.
Cube up Velveeta and melt in the microwave until soft, about 2 to 3 minutes, stirring every minute or so.
Combine the vegetables, Velveeta and soup. Add a little broth if needed – should be creamy, not thick and gloppy. Fold in pasta. Give it a gentle stir and add a little more additional broth if needed.
Bake at 350 degrees for about 30 - 40 minutes, until warmed through and bubbly. Top with almonds during last 20 minutes.
Money and Time Saving Strategies:
For pricing, remember to use your coupon matching sites for your local stores. My favorite is Pocket Your Dollars in my area, but every store has a group of enthusiastic couponers who can point you to the best bargains. Don’t be discouraged if your prices are higher at first – just keep shopping the best sales and follow the strategies and you’ll get there! Check under Saving on Basic Ingredients for more detailed information and storage hints – use <control f> to search each page to bring you to the item you want to check out.
- Chicken or Turkey: This is a great leftover dish, but either way I’ll count the protein for as little as 69 cents a pound up to 99 cents a pound, the latter being an easy price to find either on sale. 2 cups is about 8 ounces. Cost: 50 cents.
- Green Bell Pepper: You could substitute the more colorful (and more expensive colored peppers, but for this dish I do like the green better. I find it on sale all the time for 69 cents a pepper, and sometimes 59 cents. Watch the per unit and per pound pricing on the sales, and buy the largest possible on the per unit prices. Cost: 69 cents.
- Onion: At 66 a pound, an onion is about 20 cents. Store in a dark, cool place away from your potatoes. I keep mine in a paper grocery sack by my kitchen door. Pick them up in quantity when you see them on sale. I often get mine from Aldi’s.
- Celery: Celery: On sale for 98 cents, 2 stalks are about 20 cents. Remember to use your leaves, they’re full of flavor, and if you don’t use them in your cooking, save them, along with the bottom parts for soup or stock.
- Butter: On sale for Easter this week, 1 pound is $1.49 – stock up as much as you can during Holiday weeks and freeze. Three tablespoon is about 15 cents.
- Velveeta: If you object, use real cheese. We don’t use it a lot at our house, but to me, Velveeta grilled cheese are a childhood comfort thing, and it is good in this dish. If you buy, look for sales with coupons in the spring, generally around Easter, sometimes the winter holidays and often midsummer. I look for specials at the store where you buy so many Kraft items and get an extra discount or money on the next purchase. A good price is $3.99 for a 2 pound box. You’ll need about a 1/4 of the box – $1.00.
- Mushrooms: Never pay full price, they go on sale every few weeks for 99 cents for 8 ounces, or half the usual price. You can actually saute up a bunch and but in your freezer in smaller portions. Mushrooms have fantastic organic compounds and are really great for you. You’ll need about 4 ounces, cost 50 cents.
- Canned Soup: Feel free to try the Cream of Anything soup recipe. I try to stock up on a few basic canned soups in the fall, and with coupons and sales I often buy them at no cost. Easter is generally the last time you’ll see a good price on canned soup. Cost free. If you have to buy “on sale” without a coupon or offer, you can expect to pay 50 to 69 cents a can. I’ll count $1.38 cents toward the recipe.
- Chicken Broth: I always make my own with leftover bones and parts. Cost free
- Noodles: I buy the higher quality high protein pasta, with sales and coupons I haven’t paid anything for pasta for several years now. Look for coupons on the manufactures sites and on olive oil. Cost 0
- Slivered Almonds or bread crumbs: Almonds are the more expensive choice, buy with coupons, stock up and freeze during Christmas sales, and check out Aldi’s. I used breadcrumbs from leftover bread: Cost 0.
Per Serving: 459 Calories; 26g Fat (49.4% calories from fat); 25g Protein; 35g Carbohydrate; 4g Dietary Fiber; 103mg Cholesterol; 1074mg Sodium. Exchanges: 2 Grain(Starch); 2 1/2 Lean Meat; 1/2 Vegetable; 3 Fat; 1/2 Other Carbohydrates.
Put Your Own Spin on It:
You could vary the vegetables or add more in your Cheesy Chicken Noodle Casserole - sometimes I add red pepper, carrots, broccoli, etc., it’s really not particular and is a very forgiving recipe. I often use a buttered bread crumb and parmesan topping instead of the almonds. You could go with a white noodle – I really like to make this with Rototini to catch the sauce.
If you are really opposed to the Velveeta and canned soups in this, you could certainly cook your vegetables in the butter, add about three tablespoons of flour, then about 2 1/2 cups of a combination of chicken broth and milk, then about 2 – 3 cups of shredded cheese. See the recipe for “cream of anything soup.”
This is fun to make in individual ramekins as shown above, and there is the added bonus, when served this way, of your family being less likely to over eat. I like to serve this with a dark green salad or a cooked green like kale or turnip greens.
You can also make this entirely stove top, and omit the baking.
A very easy few minutes work to make this, and I have one large or two smaller casseroles with a few leftovers. I’ll often freeze one of the casseroles or take one to a friend or family in need.
Cheesy Chicken Casserole made October 2011.
This is part of my 12 Days of Turkey posting – Twelve Ways to Use those Thanksgiving Leftovers:
- Best Turkey Broth - I immediately take the carcass and put it on the stove, barely covered with water (I’ll push it down, even crack the carcass a bit) and make turkey broth. It simmers on the stove while we’re relaxing. Here’s how I do it.
- Turkey Noodle Soup - You can’t go wrong with this simple, hearty soup.
- Wild Rice and Turkey Chowder - a healthy and hearty way to use up those leftovers…and with any luck, maybe you can use your leftover wild rice, potatoes, sweet potatoes and corn, too!
- Turkey Tetrazzini - this is a dressed up canned soup variety, but I first made it as a young woman and its become a family favorite. If you’d like to go all scratch, use the recipe under Forgotten Arts for “Cream of Anything Soup.”
- Chicken Pot Pie – Made with turkey, of course!
- Chicken (or Turkey) Enchiladas - One of our favorite family recipes I picked up in Colorado.
- Uncle Ben’s Wild Rice Turkey Casserole - This dish has been around forever, but it’s a quick and easy throw together – perfect for a busy Holiday.
- Artichoke & Turkey or Chicken Casserole - This is a crowd pleaser and a gorgeous dish – think about making this one when you have a houseful of guests.
- Cheesy Chicken or Turkey Noodle Casserole - Quick and Easy and it screams “Comfort.” Serves 12, but easily 1/2′s – it freezes well, too.
- Chicken (or Turkey) Newberg - My kids always loved this old-fashioned simple sauce, served over popovers or biscuits. It takes just a few minutes to cook and is a great way to use those Turkey Leftovers.
- Filled Won Ton Cups - filled, of course, with your Leftover Turkey done up BBQ style. One of our favorite appetizer/finger foods. These truly are strangely addictive.
- BBQ Turkey Pizza or Turkey Artichoke Pizza - yeah, you can buy a grocery store take and bake or order out, but why, when this is either/and so much better and less expensive?